Four Gandhi Movements and the Distribution of Outcomes
Historical movements can be examined not only by asking what they achieved, but also by asking who received those gains, which structures remained intact, and how political leadership changed during the process. Gandhi’s political career between 1914 and 1931 offers four important cases for such a comparison. In South Africa in 1914, the Smuts-Gandhi Agreement produced specific reforms. Indian marriages were recognised and the three-pound tax was abolished. These measures represented important gains for Indian workers. However, the wider discriminatory structure remained. The Gujarati merchant community retained protection for commercial and property interests. Gandhi returned to India in 1915 with an international reputation gained through the South African Satyagraha campaigns. Tamil indentured labourers remained among the most structurally disadvantaged groups. Champaran in 1917 produced a different but related set of results. The Tinkathia system was abolished, ending com...